Bulletins
for Physics and Philosophy undergraduates
For
PP students new to
Welcome
to
For
PP students entering the 2nd year:
For
PP students entering the 3rd year:
For
PP students entering the 3rd year:
No Philosophy of Physics research seminar
will be run this Michaelmas Term
The
visiting speakers series will continue in Hilary and
Trinity Term of 2005.
Welcome the new PP undergraduate society
presidents:
anna.lewis@balliol.ox.ac.uk
and james.robinson@balliol.ox.ac.uk
Welcome also the new PP joint committee student representative
------------------For PP Undergraduates too---------------
Metaphysics of Physics
Dr J Butterfield and Mr D. Wallace,
Weds.5,
Each week we will discuss about two articles or book chapters. We propose
the following readings on Kant's philosophy of geometry for the first
meeting; and more tentatively, other readings about space and time for the
second and third meetings. We also expect to turn to metaphysical
questions about quantum physics in the second half of term. But when we
first meet, we can discuss topics, and even adjust the proposals for the
second and third meetings, in the light of people's interests. As the
choice of readings below indicates, we expect to focus firmly on
metaphysical questions---not presupposing a knowledge of physics. (There
are copies of these readings at the Philosophy Library desk.)
1) Week 1 = 16 Jan: Kant's Philosophy of Geometry
J Hopkins, 'Visual geometry', Philosophical Review 82, 1973, 3-34; and in
Kant on Pure Reason (OUP Readings) ed R
M Friedman, Kant and the Exact Sciences (Harvard UP 1992), Chap. 1,
'Geometry; an improvement of his article 'Kant's Philosophy of Geometry',
Philosophical Review 94, 1985, 455-506.
2) Week 2 = 23 Jan: Philosophy of Geometry in the light of Relativity
A. Eddington, Preface and Prologue from Space Time Gravitation (CUP,
1920); 1-16. Easy reading!
Norton 'Philosophy of Space and Time' in M.
Salmon et al Introduction to
Philosophy of Science (Prentice-Hall 1992); 179-232; reprinted in
Spacetime, ed. Butterfield, Belot and Hogarth.
3) Week 3 = 30 Jan: Relationism about Space and Time
J Barbour, 'Relational Concepts of about
Space and Time', Brit Journal of
Philosophy of Science 33, 251-274; reprinted in Spacetime, ed.
Butterfield, Belot and Hogarth.
J Butterfield, 'The End of Time?', forthcoming in BJPS; also at the Los
Alamos and